
MOREHEAD, Ky. — The closely contested race for mayor of Morehead may be headed to court after Thursday's recanvass failed to change the original election results, leaving Jim Tom Trent ahead of write-in candidate Edna Schack by a single vote.
The Rowan County Board of Elections conducted the recanvass on November 12, reviewing the vote totals from the November 3 general election.
The results remained unchanged:
Jim Tom Trent: 574 votes
Edna Schack: 573 votes
Rowan County Clerk Elwood Caudill Jr. confirmed the unchanged totals directly to The Morehead Minute on Thursday. When asked about additional developments, Caudill indicated that legal action could follow.
Schack has since confirmed directly to The Morehead Minute that she intends to pursue a formal recount.
"Hello, Joe. We do plan to request a recount," Schack said in a message to the publication.
She identified attorney Lincoln Caudill as her legal representative and directed additional questions to him.
However, information reported by LEX 18 News suggests the election dispute may involve more than simply verifying the number of votes cast.
Two Disputed Write-In Ballots
According to reporting by LEX 18 journalist Alex Barber, Schack's legal team has identified two write-in ballots that were not included in her official vote total.
Attorney Lincoln Caudill told the television station that the two ballots contained only Schack's first name, "Edna," rather than her full name.
Kentucky's election regulations contain specific requirements governing write-in votes.
Under 31 KAR 6:030, Section 4(6), a write-in vote containing only a candidate's first name is not considered valid. The regulation generally allows a vote containing only the candidate's surname, provided there is not another eligible candidate with the same surname seeking that office.
Schack's legal team reportedly intends to challenge the exclusion of the two ballots, arguing that the voters' intentions were sufficiently clear.
The potential significance is substantial. With Trent currently leading by only one vote, adding two votes to Schack's total without any other changes would reverse the candidates' positions.
However, those votes have not been added to her total, and any determination regarding their validity would have to come through the appropriate legal process.
Another Ballot Raises Questions
A separate issue involving voter eligibility could also become part of the dispute.
In Barber's report for LEX 18, Rowan County Attorney Cecil Watkins described a clerical error involving a voter's driver's license information.
According to that report, the error resulted in an individual who did not reside within Morehead being assigned to a city voting precinct, allowing that person to cast a ballot in the mayoral election.
The circumstances surrounding that ballot, including how it might affect the election, could require judicial review.
The identity of the voter, the candidate for whom the ballot was cast, and whether the ballot will ultimately affect the election's outcome have not been independently established by The Morehead Minute.
With a margin of just one vote, questions about even a single ballot could prove important.
Schack's Attorney Plans Legal Action
Lincoln Caudill told LEX 18 that he intended to pursue both a recount and a separate legal action contesting the election.
These proceedings serve different purposes.
A recanvass primarily reviews the accuracy of reported election totals, while a formal recount involves a more detailed examination of the ballots.
An election contest can raise broader legal questions, including disputes over voter eligibility and whether particular ballots should have been counted.
The fact that the recanvass produced no changes does not necessarily resolve those separate issues.
As of this report, The Morehead Minute has not independently confirmed that either legal action has been formally filed.
Trent Responds to Recanvass
Following Thursday's proceedings, Trent issued a public statement expressing confidence in the Rowan County Board of Elections and its handling of the election.
He acknowledged the possibility of continued legal proceedings and indicated that his campaign would participate in the process.
Trent also expressed appreciation for election officials and thanked his attorney, Sarah Cameron of Dinsmore Law, for representing him.
In a separate social media post, Trent encouraged his supporters to treat Schack respectfully as she considers her legal options.
He explained that if the election results were reversed and he found himself trailing by one vote, he would also seek a recount out of respect for his supporters.
His remarks suggest that, despite the extremely narrow margin and the possibility of litigation, he recognizes his opponent's right to challenge the results through the established legal process.
What Happens Next?
For now, the recanvassed results continue to show Trent ahead by one vote.
However, the election remains subject to potential legal proceedings, and several questions have yet to be resolved.
Among them are whether the two disputed write-in ballots should be counted, what legal effect the reported voter-registration error could have, and whether a recount or election contest will result in any changes to the totals.
Any such changes would depend on further review and the applicable legal process.
The Morehead Minute will continue monitoring developments, including any court filings, recount proceedings, or rulings affecting the election.
With only one vote separating the candidates, the final resolution of Morehead's mayoral race may depend not simply on the numbers reported on election night, but on how Kentucky election law applies to the disputed ballots.
Sources and Reporting Note: This article includes information obtained directly by The Morehead Minute from Rowan County Clerk Elwood Caudill Jr. and mayoral candidate Edna Schack, along with public statements issued by Jim Tom Trent. Additional reporting concerning the disputed write-in ballots, the voter-registration issue, and statements from attorneys Lincoln Caudill and Sarah Cameron was provided by LEX 18 News reporter Alex Barber in his November 13, 2026, report, Morehead mayoral race stays at 1-vote margin after recanvass, but questions remain. The applicable write-in voting regulation was independently reviewed through the Kentucky Legislative Research Commission.
